What are conservative leaders saying about protecting the ballot initiative process?

 

“For more than 100 years, Missouri voters from all sides of the political spectrum have relied on ballot measures to directly pass laws, such as constitutional limits on state and local taxation and spending. However, some status quo politicians in our state are now trying to block citizen ballot initiative petitions in a desperate power grab.

Attacks on the ballot initiative petition process in Missouri are not new — and usually arise after an issue passes that the party in power does not like. It happened in the late 1980s and early 1990s under Democratic majorities, and is happening once again under Republican majorities. Neither party was, or is, correct.

The initiative process is a power and freedom that we the people have reserved to ourselves to check and be independent of the General Assembly. Elected lawmakers and wealthy special interests want to rig this system, preferring to keep all the power to themselves by making it harder for Missourians to place important reforms on the ballot. They even want to make it easier to overturn the public’s vote.

It’s time to fight back against these misguided efforts to ensure that our laws truly reflect the will of the people. It’s time for Republican leadership in the General Assembly to fight this political censorship. We call on Missourians to join the Conservatives Against Corruption coalition to defend our liberties.

— Carl Bearden, United for Missouri

  • To the members of this committee.

    My name is Pat Holland. I live in Clever Missouri and since I have not received a call back from my Senator that I reached out to to talk about the ballot initiative legislation, I appreciate the chance to have my statement read to the committee today because I could not change my Wednesday schedule on 24 hour notice of this hearing in order to attend.

    I oppose HJR79 and any other legislation that will impose further tightening restrictions of ballot initiatives for the people to address issues important to them in this State. I understand the reason behind these legislative initiatives but I think better solutions are available.

    I have reached out to Representatives about ideas on how to achieve the same goals stated by representatives who voted to pass HJR79. In a one hour meeting with our organization, we had come up with alternative approaches to solve these issues but no one in the general assembly that we reached out to seems to want to hear them or talk about them. For this reason alone I suggest all bills having to do with ballot initiatives be killed this year and we can revisit them next year after the people of Missouri are aware of the potential problem and have a say in the potential solutions. Please stop telling the people of Missouri you have the answer because your proposed solutions do not sit well with liberty minded Missourians.

    To those who are afraid of George Soros or Michael Bloomberg having undue influence in this state due to ballot initiative proposals I say this:

    Are you not also afraid of Federal Government influence on Missouri legislation through organizations such as the Sheriff’s Association, the Missouri Police Chief’s Association and others that receive funds from the federal government and lobby Missouri General Assembly members for their special interests? This is a giant elephant in the room, no one wants to talk about this. These organizations and others are trying to do away with Missouri’s new SAPA law and they do receive federal funds and repackage them into grants. This should be discussed as passionately and as completely as the threat from the Bloomberg and Soros types. All current legislation this year to tighten ballot initiatives requirements do not address these problems with federal influence.

    When I hear a Senator or Representative say that Missouri is lucky to have a ballot initiative access for the citizens and we should not complain about making the requirements more difficult to obtain, I literally cringe. It sounds like a scripted talking point. It sounds like I should be happy with a reduced freedom, a piece of liberty being taken away for a perceived threat. It sounds like someone is taking away my meal but leaving me some crumbs to eat. It feels like when the federal government nibbles away at my freedoms and expects me to be happy with increasing federal government power and restricting my freedoms for my own safety. Benjamin Franklin had something to say about this. It was a warning about the increasing of government’s power over the people. “Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety” It did not escape my attention that the General Assembly has not tightened up the requirements for itself to get ballot initiatives on the ballot. This is hypocrisy. And it sure looks like you want to absorb some of the power from the people of Missouri into the General Assembly. This is the public perception of the bills for tightening requirements for ballot initiatives.

    If your concerns were the medicaid expansion bill, I’ll let you know that was a concern of mine too. We all failed to educate the people about what that ballot initiative represented. The general assembly failed, the media failed, the grass roots failed. We all failed. That was Everyone's fault. Why punish the people of Missouri for making a bad choice when they truly didn’t understand the choice they were making in the first place? If we take that position, it would be best for Missouri politicians to announce they need to make all decisions for the people because the people are are too dumb or lazy to investigate or understand what we are voting for. We can learn from this past mistake by making an effort to educate and communicate information about all future ballot initiatives and make sure ballot initiatives are clearly worded with no ambiguous language so folks can understand what they are voting for.

    In closing, I would like to say why most Representatives and Senators have received more phone calls, emails and visits in their offices in the past several years. The reason is simple. Grassroots organizations are popping up all over the State of Missouri. It started with the Second Amendment Preservation Act and accelerated with covid lock downs and restrictions. The General Assembly is being watched more closely than it has before. People in Missouri want more freedom, not less freedom. We need to stop competing with states that have less freedom and compete with states that have more freedom. This is where good ideas begin. It’s a good idea to include the people of Missouri in deciding the direction we go in and not tell them what needs to be done to protect them from perceived threats to our Constitution, whether internal or external. Please place your trust in the people of Missouri to do the right thing, as they have placed their trust in you to do the right thing. Please remember who you work for, and your oaths of office. May God bless you all.

“Our forebears very wisely gave the people the ability to place measures on the ballot. The legislature should fiercely guard Missouri citizens’ constitutional right to take issues directly to the people and govern ourselves."

— Former Sen. Rob Schaaf (R-St. Joseph)

"The right of the People to alter or abolish their constitution or form of government is one of the seven characteristics of an American republic identified in the Federalist Papers. Missourians even codified that claim in Article I, Section 3 of their Constitution. There is no such right if the People have to ask permission from the government to do so, and that is why the initiative petition process, and reasonable threshold for ratifying constitutional amendments are so critical if we are to preserve the Republic."

— Ron Calzone, Missouri First

“If lawmakers sincerely think we change our state Constitution too frequently, perhaps they
should look instead to get their own house in order. It's my understanding the 182 times the Constitution has been amended since 1910, 85 percent of the changes originated with the Legislature – not voters."

— Former Republican Congressman Tom Coleman (MO-6)

“The Missouri Constitution proclaims, ‘All political power is vested in, and derived from, the people …’ (Art.1 Sec.1)

Right now, our state legislators are attempting to take away that power by making the citizen ballot initiative nearly impossible.

What is needed is the opposite – to make the process more accessible to all of us.

The ballot initiative our only way to get a critical issue to a direct vote of the people.

Are the politicians who claim to represent us afraid of our collective voice and will?

Without the citizen initiative, we lose our check on those we elect.

When they act against our freedom and security, or fail act to protect it, what recourse do we have? By the next election the damage is done, and will likely never be undone. 

And many are expert at masking their responsibility for it.

I would encourage each of you to let your state representatives, senators and our governor know we are watching and will hold them personally responsible if they attempt to silence our voice or fail to fight for our right to express it.”

— James Coyne, Mid-Missouri Patriots

 

Attacks on the people’s right to take action aren’t new.

For example, in Missouri, Democrats tried to block Constitutional freedoms in 1992, but Governor John Ashcroft vetoed the move.

“It is through the initiative process that those who have no influence with elective representatives may take their cause directly to the people. The General Assembly should be reluctant, therefore, to enact legislation which places any impediments on the initiative power which are inconsistent with the reservation found in the Constitution.”

— Governor John Ashcroft (R-MO)

 

For over 100 years, Americans have used the initiative process to bypass dysfunction and directly get things done for the people.

 

1980: Missouri citizens organized and passed the Hancock Amendment to limit state and local taxes and spending—over the objections of special interests and politicians.

2010: Missouri citizens worked together to ban unfair double taxation on real estate transactions.

2016: Missouri citizens overrode politicians and reformed pay-to-play corruption of money in politics.